Firm vs Soft Mattress: Which is Best?

The feel of a hard versus soft mattress is the most noticeable distinction. A firm mattress feels more solid to the touch. When pressure is applied to a softer mattress, it will quickly compress. It’s vital to note that mattress feel isn’t simply divided into two groups; instead, it’s a continuum. This means you have many options, which can be a good thing and a bad thing. 

All materials can be used to make mattresses of any type. The spring tension or the general tension of construction within the mattress determines the firmness or softness of a mattress. On the other hand, a mattress can have an outer covering or upholstery that alters the firmness perception.

What is a Firm Mattress?

If you’re thinking of buying a regular lower back latex foam or innerspring mattress, you might want to reconsider. There are a few advantages to it. One is that you don’t feel as if you’re sinking into it and that your movement is restricted, on the other hand, it lacks support and may flex down throughout the night, causing back pain.

A firm mattress will support your pressure areas, such as your shoulders and hips while allowing the rest of your body to droop. Because your body only has support at the pressure points, this is the case. It doesn’t support your lower back or lumbar region. Thus your spine in that location may lose its curvature due to the lack of support.

Advantages

  • Suitable for Heavy Sleepers: Firm is the optimal mattress firmness for persons who are heavy. A medium-firm or firm mattress should suffice in most circumstances, while an ultra-firm mattress may be required in extreme cases. The firmness of a mattress is also determined by its support system, which refers to how your body responds to any stiffer core or innerspring system.
  • Suitable for Back and Stomach Sleepers: For stomach sleepers, firm mattresses are excellent because they keep your spine in a neutral posture, preventing it from dropping into the bed and causing back pain. Medium firmness beds provide a balanced level of pressure alleviation and support, whilst hard beds provide the most support.
  • Improves Circulation: Reduces the amount of pressure on your circulatory system, allowing you to take in more oxygen while sleeping. You can relieve pressure on your circulatory system by sleeping on a hard mattress. This, in turn, aids in the improvement of blood flow within your body.
  • Prevents Overheating: A soft mattress provides better insulation because it conforms to the body. A soft mattress can induce warmth and sleep disruptions if you’re a hot sleeper. Firm beds allow more air to travel across the bed’s surface, reducing the likelihood of night sweats waking you up.

They are more long-lasting and durable. Firm mattresses are designed to be durable and prevent people from sinking into them. As a result, you can rest assured that your mattress will survive for years to come. It is capable of being more adaptable. You can use a mattress topper or support pillows to assist you in getting used to a new mattress if it’s too hard to adjust to at first. It allows you to adjust the firmness or softness of the bed to your preferences.

Drawbacks

  • Too Firm For Petite Sleepers: Lightweight sleepers may have unpleasant pressure points around their joints if they sleep on a mattress that is overly firm. These sleepers require a bed that is softer and has more excellent compression to protect and cushion the body’s curvature.
  • Can Worsen Arthritis, Joint, and Scoliosis Pain: For people who suffer from joint and muscle pain, this is not a good option. As previously indicated, those with joint and muscle discomfort may require soft support to assist relieve chronic pain. That support can be found in a soft mattress. It’s possible that it’ll make your lower back ache worse. A firm bed, depending on a person’s discomfort, may aggravate lower back pain since it lacks gentle support.
  • Can Feel Uncomfortable Initially: On the surface, switching from a softer to a more challenging mattress can be highly inconvenient. With time, this becomes less obvious.

What is a Soft Mattress?

As you sleep, a softer mattress will accommodate your natural spinal curve. However, the absence of support may gradually cause the rest of your body to sag, causing you to go back into a wrong sleeping position. A soft mattress may feel nice at first, but as you sink deeper into it, you may become hot at night. The support provided by soft mattresses is less than that provided by their more rigid counterparts. Many people prefer fluffy mattresses that are fluffy and have a cloud-like feel to them. The same is true for side sleepers, as this posture frequently necessitates additional cushioning for the shoulders and hips to maintain proper alignment and reduce strain along the spine.

Advantages

  • Convenient for Side Sleepers: Soft mattresses provide better pressure alleviation, so side sleepers shouldn’t experience too much pressure on their shoulders and hips. A medium-soft mattress can give the essential support while softly cradling the hips and shoulders, decreasing stress and damage for side sleepers.
  • Suitable for Lightweight Sleepers: Soft mattresses, which cradle and mold to the body, are frequently preferred by people who weigh less than 130 pounds.
  • Suitable for Arthritis and Joint Pain Patients: Aids in the relief of joint and muscle discomfort. Soft mattresses aren’t as firm mattresses, making them excellent for people who suffer from joint and muscular pain. It makes it easier for the joints and muscles to be supported. Helps to align the hips. Soft mattresses provide light support, making them an excellent choice for individuals suffering from hip pain.
  • Reduces Pressure Points: Soft mattresses provide a larger support area and also minimize pressure points.

Drawbacks

  • Mattress May Appear Unstable for Couples:  It isn’t always the best option for couples. Couples have varying levels of comfort and requirements.
  • Create Issue for Plus-Sized Adults: A softer mattress may not be able to meet the needs of each individual. Those with a heavier body weight may find it uncomfortable. Because softer mattresses allow a person to sink gently into the mattress, a person with a more significant body weight may discover that a softer mattress wears out faster in the long run. 
  • Extra Exposed to Sagging: For a heavier person, a firmer mattress might provide better sleep quality. Because softer mattresses aren’t as firm as firmer mattresses, they tend to wear out within a few years of purchase.
  • Can Be Difficult for Back and Stomach Sleepers: Stomach sleepers have a hard time keeping their spine in excellent alignment. Their midsections may sink too deeply into a mattress that is too soft. Soft mattresses disrupt spine alignment hence it is problematic for back sleepers.

Choosing between a firm mattress and a soft mattress shouldn’t be that tough in the end. The first step in obtaining the ideal mattress is deciding whether one prefers firm or soft comfort.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, a soft mattress is good for the back as it supports the back.

After a year or two, firm mattresses get softer.

Hotels provide soft mattresses.

Firm mattresses are best for sleep as they relieve the body and help them to be stress-free.

Mattress thickness influences your comfort since resting on a mattress that is either thin or too thick can induce poor sleep and have a negative impact on your health. The height or depth of the mattress is sometimes referred to as its thickness. Exceptionally deep or extra tall mattresses are mattresses that are thicker than 16 inches.

No, it doesn’t matter how tall you are. Usually, you spend more for more status and good appearances rather than for more support and comfort. A mattress can be anywhere from 6″ to 12-15″ in height, depending on whether it’s made of memory foam or latex organic foam.

Was this article helpful?

Related reading

Fact-Checking: Our Process

The Mattressguides editorial team is dedicated to providing content that meets the highest standards for accuracy and objectivity. Our editors and medical experts rigorously evaluate every article and guide to ensure the information is factual, up-to-date, and free of bias.

The Mattressguides fact-checking guidelines are as follows: